Northwestern Gothic?

Cade Caldwell had lost two fingers on his left hand. This was painful to look at but no big deal really. You see, the year after his accident one of his granddaughters was born with six fingers on each of her hands.

“See?” his family said, “The Lord taketh away and the Lord giveth.” They figured on waiting until her fingers grew to about the size of Cade’s then relocating them. “Make do or do without” was another popular saying among the members of the Caldwell family and they settled back to watch until Nature would take her course.